tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2807719883052252139.post6363446385723818418..comments2023-09-24T17:56:38.272+05:30Comments on Meena's Space: Book Review: "Two States ~~ The story of my Marriage" - Chatan Bhagat-Mina Menonhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/04652075943354242372noreply@blogger.comBlogger7125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2807719883052252139.post-28008154359490977192009-12-03T13:57:20.062+05:302009-12-03T13:57:20.062+05:30It is not as good as his earlier works...Though go...It is not as good as his earlier works...Though good for one time read.I'm a hardcore chetan fan But i was bit disappointed with this book,may be coz of my over expectation...between nice review :)Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2807719883052252139.post-25149067571705624922009-12-03T13:56:15.168+05:302009-12-03T13:56:15.168+05:30This comment has been removed by the author.Anish Thomas (I have moved to http://anishthomas.wordpress.com/ )https://www.blogger.com/profile/16296711774642090998noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2807719883052252139.post-78090694220488991132009-11-19T14:13:34.279+05:302009-11-19T14:13:34.279+05:30SABINA~U ROCK :)SABINA~U ROCK :)Kannanhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/05224688290098279820noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2807719883052252139.post-58238958959230210902009-11-12T08:17:43.594+05:302009-11-12T08:17:43.594+05:30idealistic is not the case with all of us...i don&...idealistic is not the case with all of us...i don't agree...please correct it to some of us...then what do i say about the marraiges of friends i know across the globe which do not fit into any conventional framework...so what is convenient and subscribed by a majority of opportunists is reality...love that philosophy!!...and if not for ideals we,nay the next generation would be living in an unscrupulous decadent and regressive world.so beware!! grow up and start thinking out of the box:)sabinasabinahttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13913935684390004992noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2807719883052252139.post-31749667071668651892009-11-09T18:11:58.103+05:302009-11-09T18:11:58.103+05:30@Sabi, what u say is absolutely right...But well i...@Sabi, what u say is absolutely right...But well in a idealistic world which isnt the case at all with us...so please get back to reality :)Mina Menonhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/04652075943354242372noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2807719883052252139.post-28895271546153719452009-11-09T18:06:37.171+05:302009-11-09T18:06:37.171+05:30OK the last comment was quite a mouthful. I am yet...OK the last comment was quite a mouthful. I am yet to read this book and I plan to read it asap. Further comments after thatThirteenth Manhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/03556740657741377569noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2807719883052252139.post-11909533765239699462009-11-09T17:57:26.369+05:302009-11-09T17:57:26.369+05:30At the outset I should admit that I have not read ...At the outset I should admit that I have not read Chetan Bhagat’s ‘ Two States' nor am I planning to read it...but I did read the blurb and went through a few reviews before I wrote this response(since the post was for me ;)...well, I believe the success ingredient for any marriages to succeed( love, arranged, contrived, manipulated or call it what you may!) are much the same...trust, mutual respect and an unconditional love between the partners, not to say the "working on the relationship" which is absolutely essential to keep it going...I feel winning over the families is secondary and seems too contrived, manipulative and ridiculous although that predominates the conventional Indian marriage scenario...seems ironical that those who choose their own partners also have the arduous task of “winning over” the in-laws and outlaws for a decision which should actually be honoured for being responsible and individualistic in finding their own spouses just as they have earned their degrees and jobs and in many ways not draining the parents off money as gifts and lavish banquets in the name of conventional marriages...even if this maybe funny yet realistic as you say, I refuse to get this “hypocritical logic” straight ...so the Meenas in the world can read Chetan Bhagat as bedtime story to your kids as they grow up...and make karan johar’s “all about loving the family series” as mealtime entertainers and force-feed generation Y on it and wait for them to “win you over” maybe as chetan did by buying you gold rings or something ...and brag to society hypocritically about the virtues of your Punjabi or Marathi son/daughter-in-law...although I personally believe that your husband will accept an eskimo or an aborigine for a son/daughter-in-law any day... with no (wedding) strings attached!! <br />PS. The views expressed above are entirely personal and not meant to denigrate a person or a prevalent system in India. <br />Sabinasabinahttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13913935684390004992noreply@blogger.com